You can move an existing HSA to any provider you want, even if you no longer have a high-deductible health plan. You can’t make new contributions without an HSA-eligible plan, but transferring an old balance into a new account doesn’t require one. You’re never locked in with a bad HSA provider.

I assumed I was stuck with the provider my employer picked. No disrespect to the employer, but that HSA was awful: maintenance fees, poor fund options, cash minimums. Over the years that probably cost me thousands. Today I opened a new HSA and transferred everything.1

One note: ask for a trustee-to-trustee transfer, not a rollover. A transfer moves the money directly between providers, isn’t taxed, and you can do it as often as you want. A rollover sends the check to you, gives you 60 days to redeposit it, and is limited to one per 12 months.

The same goes for an HSA you’re still contributing to. Your employer’s payroll deposits go to the provider they chose, but nothing stops you from opening your own HSA elsewhere and transferring the balance out periodically.

Old news for some of you, I’m sure, but it was news to me.


  1. What to look for in a provider: no maintenance fee, no cash minimum, and low-cost index funds. I chose Fidelity on those grounds; I have no affiliation with them. ↩︎